| 1997 | N/A |
| 1998 | Rachael Wheatley – 290 PTS |
| 1999 | Kimberley Walsh – 445 PTS |
| 2000 | Nicola Sharp – 720 PTS |
| 2001 | Hannah Conlin – 540 PTS |
| 2002 | Hannah Conlin – 830 PTS |
| 2003 | Toni Anderson – 610 PTS |
| 2004 | Toni Anderson – 700 PTS |
| 2005 | Zoe Raw – 700 PTS |
| 2006 | Zoe Raw – 610 PTS |
| 2007 | Ashleigh Huntsman – 670 PTS |
| 2008 | Emma Thompson – 320 PTS |
| 2009 | Katie Howe – 795 PTS |
| 2010 | Katie Howe – 820 PTS |
| 2011 | Megan Hopper – 614 PTS |
| 2012 | Samantha Verrill – 800 PTS |
| 2013 | Samantha Verrill – 779 PTS |
| 2014 | Robyn Jones – 727 PTS |
| 2015 | Niamh Stinton – 627 PTS |
| 2016 | Rachael Rose – 700 PTS |
| 2017 | Rachael Rose – 666 PTS |
| 2018 | Kacey Eyeington – 915 PTS |
| 2019 | Isabel Mayes – 930 PTS |
| 2021 | Sophia Cordery – 421 PTS |
| 2022 | Florence Levell – 810 PTS |
| 2023 | Beatrice Massey – 749 PTS |
| 2024 | Annabelle Carter – 765 PTS |
| 2025 | Annabelle Carter – 765 PTS |
Cleveland Wheelers 